ESG Rating Disagreement: A Review of Sources, Economic Consequences, and Research Directions

Environmental, social, and governance (ESG) ratings inform investment decisions, yet providers often disagree about the same company. This narrative review synthesizes 25 publications on the conceptual foundations, measurement, determinants, and economic consequences of ESG rating disagreement. It distinguishes differences in rating scope, indicator measurement, and weighting from differences in the reliability and interpretation of corporate information. The reviewed evidence indicates that greater disclosure does not necessarily increase agreement, whereas external assurance is associated with lower disagreement in some settings. Financial consequences also vary: studies report relationships with stock returns, equity financing costs, analyst forecasts, audit fees, and pricing efficiency, with opposing findings for some outcomes. The review interprets these contrasts through a distinction between information-related, methodological, and preference-driven disagreement. These categories offer an analytical framework rather than an empirically estimated decomposition. Priorities for future research include comparable disagreement measures, disclosure quality, digital information systems, industry and institutional differences, and stronger identification of causal mechanisms. The synthesis suggests that rating users should examine what providers measure and how they construct scores before interpreting disagreement as either information failure or useful diversity.

Keywords: ESG rating disagreement; corporate sustainability; information asymmetry; sustainable finance; sustainability disclosure; narrative review.